Riverside’s Arts Grants Demand More Than an Inspector General Review

Taxpayers deserve an accounting of who authorized the spending, who changed the awards, and whether the watchdog is sufficiently independent to examine City Hall’s leadership.

Riverside should have to explain every dollar it awards to private organizations: who approved it, what authorized the payment, why that recipient was selected, and what the public received. The arts-grant controversy raises serious questions about those basic responsibilities.

My position is straightforward. Riverside should stop using discretionary taxpayer grants to subsidize private arts and nonprofit operating budgets. Those organizations should build support through donors, memberships, sponsorships, foundations, and earned revenue. City Hall should concentrate its resources and management attention on essential services, infrastructure, and financial discipline.

The immediate problem also demands an accounting of money already allocated. Sending that problem to an Inspector General does not relieve the Mayor and Council of responsibility for the government they lead.

Riverside arts grants: $410,050 in FY2026–27 awards preserved; $414,150 in FY2027–28 funding paused, subject to existing legal obligations, with findings due within six months before the pause can be lifted. The 2024 and 2026 grant cycles are under review. Open questions concern authorization, changed recommendations, and oversight of appointing officials. Keith Nelson favors ending discretionary operating grants and building private support.
The Council’s decision, the open oversight questions, and my position on future funding. Select the infographic to view it at full size.

Start with the authority to spend

The Raincross Gazette reports that Council preserved $410,050 for 27 organizations in the current fiscal year while pausing $414,150 in second-year funding and new awards pending a review of the 2024 and 2026 grant cycles. Councilmember Sean Mill said approximately $1 million in 2024 awards lacked Council approval. The November 17 motion limited the pause to what existing legal obligations permit and required findings and recommendations to return to Council within six months, before the pause could be lifted. Gazette report; Council meeting, approximately 1:26–1:28.

The discussion exposed several matters that require answers. Mill said staff changed the outside panel’s recommendations for 25 of 27 organizations in 2026. Parks Deputy Director Margery Haupt said the former City Manager directed increases for certain organizations in the earlier cycle; she could not find a written directive from him. Finance Director Julie Nemes explained that verification of Council approval depended on the requesting department marking that approval was required. She also said a Finance manager challenged a submission marked otherwise, prompting Finance to require a Council report before further program payments. City Attorney James Johnson agreed that the City Manager lacked authority to make the 2024 awards. Investigators still need to reconstruct the underlying transactions. Council record, approximately 0:43, 1:07–1:12, and 1:14–1:15.

Budgeting money for a program and authorizing particular awards are separate decisions. A payment system should verify both. A department’s assertion that Council approval is unnecessary should never substitute for verifying the authority to commit public funds.

The records should establish who requested each payment, who approved it, what authority they relied on, and which controls should have stopped an unauthorized payment. They should also show how the City responded once the problem was identified.

Mill expressly said he was not alleging wrongdoing. That matters. Missing authorization, inconsistent procedures, favoritism, and criminal misuse are different findings requiring different evidence. The public can insist on an explanation of a serious control failure without pretending the investigation has already established a crime. Gazette report.

Independent scoring must have a traceable result

In my view, discretionary grants are political decisions about which organizations taxpayers will subsidize. Calling a selection process independent does not settle whether the final decisions were unbiased.

The October 6 staff report describes an outside panel followed by staff finalizing recommendations. It lists the proposed recipients and amounts, but it does not provide a comparison showing the panel’s original recommendations and each subsequent adjustment. October 6 Council memorandum.

Residents should be able to see that comparison. For every change, the City should identify the decision-maker, the written reason, the governing rule, and any relevant conflict disclosure. That would allow the public to judge whether the same standards applied to every applicant.

An organization’s familiarity, popularity, or relationship with City Hall should not substitute for an announced standard. A longstanding recipient should have to justify its claim on taxpayers just as a new applicant would.

My concern is political preference operating through discretionary adjustments. The way to test that concern is to release the records and examine the decisions. We should expect a review capable of confirming favoritism where evidence supports it and rejecting allegations where it does not.

I raised the independence problem years ago

I was raising these independence concerns years before the current arts-grant controversy.

The City’s May 5, 2022 report confirms that the Board of Ethics voted in September 2021 to obtain outside counsel for a complaint involving Councilmember Chuck Conder. It also confirms the Board’s discretion to obtain outside legal advice on specific matters. City Attorney’s report, file 22-1405.

In “Regrets – Time Wasted,” published in October 2022, and my March 2024 article on the Ethics Board, I described my concern that Council politics were compromising the ethics process. I wrote about due process, outside counsel, and the need for oversight insulated from the officials being scrutinized. Those articles record the warnings I made and my assessment of that experience.

I returned to the same issue in “Riverside’s Appointed Inspector General Is Not Real Oversight,” published March 6, 2026.

The City also had a different model before it. Its August 2022 announcement states that the Charter Review Committee originally proposed direct election of the Inspector General before Council advanced an appointed position. The structural choice was deliberate. City announcement, August 3, 2022.

The appointment structure still deserves scrutiny

Measure L’s Charter language gives the Mayor and Council selection and removal authority. The Inspector General serves “at the pleasure of the City Council and Mayor.” Council must provide sufficient funding, and the office submits its budget through the City Manager. The same section prohibits political interference, provides access to City records, and requires public reporting. Those protections are real and belong in any fair account of the office. Measure L, Section 420, printed page RV029-024; City Attorney’s impartial analysis.

I remain unconvinced that those safeguards adequately insulate an officer whose continued appointment depends on officials the office may need to investigate. In March, I called this model a waste of taxpayer money in its present form. That criticism concerns the design and the dependence it preserves.

Lori Cox deserves the opportunity to demonstrate what she can accomplish. The City announced her appointment in October, with a starting office budget of $712,000. The public should judge her work on the evidence and expect that investment to produce an effective examination of leadership decisions as well as departmental practices. City appointment announcement, October 6, 2026.

For this review, the City should publish how conflicts will be handled, how the Inspector General will obtain independent legal advice when needed, and how findings will reach the public. The review should examine the actions of senior management and the adequacy of Council oversight wherever the evidence leads.

A promise of noninterference needs practical protection. Riverside should revisit an elected office or an appointment process insulated from the officials under review, along with a fixed term, removal standards, and dependable funding. Any redesign should make it harder to retaliate against inconvenient findings and easier for residents to see what the office accomplishes.

Private organizations should build private support

Even a perfectly administered grant program would leave the policy question: why should Riverside taxpayers subsidize these organizations’ operating budgets?

My answer is that discretionary arts and nonprofit grants should give way to private fundraising. Organizations that provide valued programs can ask residents, patrons, businesses, and foundations to support them. Supporters can make that choice directly.

The City’s guidelines already evaluate diversified financial support and active fundraising. They also expressly allow administrative salaries as a use of grant funds. 2026–2028 grant guidelines, pages 2–3.

A nonprofit label does not answer whether compensation is reasonable, whether an organization has substantial reserves, or whether its programs deliver enough value to justify a subsidy. Taxpayers asked to support an organization should be able to review its applicable public filings, executive compensation, reserves, fundraising results, and use of the award.

I want those figures disclosed before anyone claims that a City subsidy is indispensable. Any claim of excessive salaries should be demonstrated with the organization’s actual records.

The strongest argument for public arts funding is that some benefits are shared widely, including by people who cannot pay. Supporters also argue that stable grants help organizations plan. Those arguments deserve a public hearing. They still require a choice about priorities and a credible explanation of why the benefit should be financed by taxpayers.

My position remains that discretionary operating grants should end. If the City needs a nonprofit to deliver a defined public service, it should contract for that service through a transparent agreement specifying the need, cost, selection process, deliverables, and performance requirements. Residents should be able to assess what the agreement purchases and whether the organization delivered it. Those contracts should not become a way to continue discretionary operating subsidies under another name.

Financial discipline starts with leadership

At Riverside’s June 23 budget hearing, staff presented approximately $17.9 million in first-year cost reductions and $22.3 million in second-year reductions across the General Fund and Measure Z. Staff described higher costs and slower revenue growth, alongside a balanced General Fund outlook and strong reserves. Those conditions call for priorities and restraint. June 23 Council record, approximately 2:40–2:45 and 2:50.

Discretionary grants belong in that examination, alongside executive recruitment, compensation, separation agreements, and the results achieved by senior management.

The Gazette’s June reporting described Mike Futrell’s separation terms as nine months of salary and retirement contributions plus one month of health benefits. That is a reported contractual cost that deserves a complete public accounting. Gazette report, June 23, updated June 25, 2026.

Residents should be told the full cost of an executive’s recruitment, employment, departure, and replacement, along with the performance expected and delivered. An expensive hiring process does not excuse an inadequate appointment. A separation payment does not close the question of who supervised that executive and how problems were addressed.

The Council appoints the City Manager and other key officers within Riverside’s council-manager government. That responsibility requires sustained evaluation of performance and controls. The Mayor’s public leadership should reinforce that accountability. City Council’s description of Riverside’s government.

My criticism is that elected leadership must answer for the quality of its appointments and supervision. If managers can direct spending without adequate authority, the review must examine the people who made those decisions and the oversight that failed to catch them. Responsibility should follow the evidence through the management chain.

The comments point toward a public debate

Under the Gazette’s Facebook post, I said I had no confidence in a watchdog handpicked by the officials it should oversee. Other visible comments raised competing needs such as roads, public health, and public safety. Some welcomed the review. Those reactions expose questions City Hall should answer openly.

Allegations of misappropriation or influence peddling require evidence. The grant controversy already provides enough documented questions to demand serious scrutiny without treating every comment as a finding.

Residents can engage now by asking for three concrete things:

  1. An award and payment accounting: original recommendations, later changes, decision-makers, approvals, agreements, and disbursements for both cycles.
  2. An accountable review: a published scope, conflict procedures, a public timetable, findings that explain responsibility, and corrective actions with named owners and completion dates.
  3. A public funding debate: whether discretionary nonprofit grants should continue at all, what private funding alternatives exist, and how essential services and infrastructure rank against those subsidies.

Preserving records and examining existing obligations should proceed immediately. A review period should also be time for residents to examine policy, rather than a reason to postpone the conversation.

This is the debate I want Riverside to have: how public money is authorized, how leaders are held responsible, and how oversight earns public confidence. I intend this series to make those questions concrete and invite residents to challenge the answers, including mine.

The Mayor, Council, nonprofit boards, donors, and residents should participate now. We already have decisions and records to examine.

Related RAP coverage

Leave a Reply

Discover more from How my mind sees the world

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading